ASOS Online : The Look For Less

I recently ordered a cardigan and shirt online that I thought were really cute and at awesome prices.  As I was browsing the ASOS site today, I saw some similar tops at some not-so-awesome prices.

Check it out.  Would you be happy with the substitutes or splurge for the pricey tops?

Equipment Silk Daddy Shirt in Fruit Print via ASOS
$477.22

Garnet Hill Merino Signature Cardigan in Vintage Lemons $49.99

Paul & Joe Sister Elephant Print Shirt via ASOS
$240

Gap Fitted Boyfriend Popover Shirt in Elephant Print
$49.95